LM-80: measuring actual LED lumen maintenance
ANSI/IES LM-80-21 measures how light output from an identified solid-state light source changes over time under specified test conditions, including temperature. Its report states the actual duration, temperatures and sample size; those details matter when assessing a subsequent projection.
For example, 10,000 hours of measurement represent about 14 months of continuous testing. A calculation for 100,000 hours would reach ten times beyond those measured data. Whether that figure can be reported under TM-21 depends on its applicable reporting limit.
In practice
- IES LM-80 measures the LED component only — not the complete luminaire. The driver, optics, thermal management, and housing all affect actual lumen maintenance in the field.
- LM-80 test data for the identified LED source are a prerequisite for a TM-21 projection. Without them, the claim has no TM-21 basis; other methods exist for testing and projecting whole-luminaire flux maintenance.
- Compare the tested source and temperatures with its operating point in the proposed luminaire. The luminaire's thermal design affects that point.
- Ask for the LM-80 test report, not just the projected figure. The test duration and the number of test samples are stated in the report and are material to the reliability of the projection.
TM-21: projecting beyond the test data
ANSI/IES TM-21-21 describes a method for projecting longer-term flux maintenance of LED light sources from LM-80 measurements. The fitted model is a projection, not a measurement of the projected operating period.
ANSI/IES TM-21-21 limits the result that may be reported from LM-80 data according to the measured duration and sample size. The commonly used limit is six times the test duration for at least 20 units and 5.5 times for 10–19 units. A calculated value beyond the applicable limit must not be presented as the TM-21 reported result.
With 10,000 hours of qualifying LM-80 data, neither a sixfold nor a 5.5-fold reporting limit reaches 100,000 hours. Request the reported TM-21 result, sample size and original ANSI/IES LM-80-21 report for the identified LED source.
Reading the notation: L70, L80, L90, B10, B50
Lumen maintenance claims combine an L-value (the percentage of initial flux that remains) with a B-value (the percentage of a luminaire population that has fallen below that L-threshold) and an hour figure. A complete notation looks like:
Read as: under the stated conditions, no more than 10% of the operating population is projected to fall below 70% of initial flux by 60,000 hours.
At the same L-threshold, time, conditions and evidence basis, B10 denotes a lower share of the operating population below the threshold than B50. That alone does not establish a longer luminaire life or make B10 a better procurement requirement. EN 13201 calls for maintained lighting performance in the project; it does not prescribe B10. Compare the declared scope and supporting evidence, and assess abrupt failures separately.
Why a headline figure may not describe the installation
Check these distinctions before applying a stated source-life figure to the complete luminaire:
- Test temperature vs operating temperature: the source's temperature in the proposed luminaire must be related to the relevant test conditions. If it operates hotter, lumen depreciation may differ from the reported projection.
- Component ageing beyond the LED: LM-80 source data do not cover driver failure or changes to the complete optical system, including ageing and contamination.
- Projection beyond TM-21 limits: a calculation may extend beyond the applicable reporting limit, but the additional hours are not a reportable TM-21 result.
- B-value not stated: under the IEC median-useful-life convention, an L70 declaration uses B50 implicitly. Without the stated convention, product scope and evidence basis, a bare "L70 > 100,000 h" claim is insufficient for comparison. B50 concerns operating products; abrupt failures need separate assessment.
What to ask instead
Rather than accepting a headline hour figure, a more productive procurement approach is to ask for the underlying data:
- LM-80 test report: how many hours did the test run, at what temperatures, and how many samples were tested?
- Reported TM-21 L70 and L80 results, with the applicable projection limit and identified LED source. TM-21 alone does not establish B10; ask for the separate basis of any By declaration.
- Operating temperature of the LED module in the actual luminaire at rated drive current — measured, not calculated.
- System-level lumen maintenance, accounting for driver efficiency over time and optical component ageing.
These questions are not unreasonable for infrastructure procurement with a 20-year planning horizon. A manufacturer who cannot provide the underlying test report is asking you to accept a projected figure with no independent basis for verification.
Hours are only part of the picture
A long service life is only valuable if the total cost of owning that service life is understood.
How to compare the purchase price of a luminaire against its energy cost, maintenance, and eventual replacement cost over a 20-year lifecycle — in a framework that holds up to public procurement scrutiny.
Procurement & Standards
Purchase price vs lifecycle cost
A framework for comparing purchase price with energy, maintenance and replacement costs over the planned operating period.
Summary
A 100,000-hour claim is meaningful only with its L threshold, product level, test conditions and reported projection limit. An LM-80/TM-21 result describes the identified LED source; LM-84/TM-28 can describe lamp or luminaire luminous-flux maintenance. Compare driver reliability and abrupt failures separately.
A value calculated beyond the applicable TM-21 reporting limit is not the same as a reported TM-21 result. Ask for the full test and projection reports, the Lx and By convention, and the operating point in the offered luminaire.
Sources and further reading
- Illuminating Engineering Society — ANSI/IES LM-80-21, Measuring Maintenance of Light Output Characteristics of Solid-State Light Sources
- Illuminating Engineering Society — ANSI/IES TM-21-21, Projecting Long-Term Luminous, Photon, and Radiant Flux Maintenance of LED Light Sources
- Illuminating Engineering Society — ANSI/IES LM-84-20+E1, Measuring Optical Radiation Maintenance of LED Lamps, Light Engines, and Luminaires
- Illuminating Engineering Society — ANSI/IES TM-28-20, Projecting Long-Term Luminous Flux Maintenance of LED Lamps and Luminaires